Sunday, July 17, 2011

Peer Support

I was on a chat thread for professionals working in the mental health and addiction field and the topic of peer support became heated.  I was surprised that this topic caused such a divide because the agencies I have come into contact with had such a positive view of peer support.  What are the pros and cons of peer support?  In my opinion and experience peer support is an integral part of the circle of care.  I embrace them as part of the team.  They have been there, they understand clients on a level most professionals do not.

So what does peer support look like?

An article I came across directly addresses the role of a peer support worker and identifies why they are problematic:

Part of what makes the ethical delivery of recovery support services so challenging in the addictions context is that the recovery coach performs so many roles. In service organizations piloting this role, the recovery coach is being described as a(n):

• outreach worker (identifies and engages hard-to-reach individuals; offers living proof of transformative power of recovery; makes recovery attractive),
• motivator and cheerleader (exhibits faith in capacity for change; encourages and celebrates recovery achievements; mobilizes internal and external recovery resources; encourages self-advocacy and economic self-sufficiency),
• ally and confidant (genuinely cares and listens; can be trusted with confidences),
• truth-teller (provides feedback on recovery progress),
• role model and mentor (offers his/her life as living proof of the transformative power of recovery; provides stage-appropriate recovery education),
 • planner (facilitates the transition from a professional-directed treatment plan to consumer-developed and consumer-directed personal recovery plan),
• resource broker (links individuals/families to formal and indigenous sources of sober housing, recovery-conducive employment, health and social services, and recovery support; matches individuals to particular support groups/meetings),
• monitor (processes each client’s response to professional services and mutual aid exposure to enhance service/support engagement, reduce attrition, resolve problems in the service/support relationship, and facilitate development of a long-term, sobriety-based support network; provides periodic face-to-face, telephonic or email-based monitoring of recovery stability and, when needed, provides early re-intervention and recovery re-initiation services),
• tour guide (introduces newcomers into the local culture of recovery; provides an orientation to recovery roles, rules, rituals, language, and etiquette; opens opportunities for broader community participation),
• advocate (helps individuals and families navigate complex service systems):
• educator (provides each client with normative information about the stages of recovery; informs professional helpers, the community, and potential service consumers about the prevalence, pathways, and styles of long-term recovery), • community organizer (helps develop and expand available recovery support resources; enhances cooperative relationships between professional service organizations and indigenous recovery support groups; cultivates opportunities for people in recovery to participate in volunteerism and other acts of service to the community),

• lifestyle consultant/guide (assists individuals/families to develop sobriety-based rituals of daily living; encourages activities (across religious, spiritual, and secular) frameworks that enhance life meaning and purpose), and
• friend (provides sober companionship; a social bridge from the culture of addiction to the culture of recovery) (White, 2004a).

I have worked on a team with those in a peer support role and their insight was very valuable for the entire team. Clients connected with peer supporters in a way that they were not able to with other professional staff. The staff took on many of the tasks outlined but not exclusively, other staff took on many of the same roles. The peer support workers that I was on a team with did have more boundaries in place and were more focused in their responsibilities.

Another article defined peer support as:

Peer-Based Recovery Support:

• Peer-based recovery support (P-BRS) is the process of giving and receiving non-professional, non-clinical assistance to achieve long-term recovery from alcohol and/or other drug-related problems.
• Peer-based recovery support is provided by people who are experientially credentialed.
• There are substantial differences between models of peer recovery support and models of professionally directed addiction treatment.
• P-BRS can be delivered through a variety of organizational venues and a variety of service roles (including paid and volunteer recovery support specialists).
• The governance structures of P-BRS vary in the span and degree of peer control (for example, peer-owned, peer-directed, and peer-delivered).

The concern expressed in the chat thread were around concerns over peers not being able to get to the root issue and only sharing their own experiences. The question one member shared was without getting to the root issue how are they actually helping the situation? I would challenge that argument by stating that the problem is not the type of support, the problem would be if that was the sole support provided. People going through treatment require support from many sources, some may benefit from the type of support a peer would provide. 

 

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Co-existing disorders

Subbu J. Sarma, MD, attending psychiatrist at Research Psychiatric Center (RPC), speaks to the methodology of treating patients suffering from co-occurring disorders during their stay at RPC (patients with both addictions and mental health conditions). The co-occurring disorders program ties both the addictive behaviors with the mental health condition in such a way that the patient is better able to understand how these interact with one another to affect their life.


Monday, July 4, 2011

Addiction Research : The ethical dilemma (Part 2)

In the second of a 3 part series, I will examine another ethical dilemma surrounding the use of addicts as research subjects. In part one I looked at issue surrounding consent. In part 2 I will look at issues surrounding the risks and benefits to the subject.

Different research projects vary in the extent to which they aim to benefit the participants and the risk of harm they contain.

In the context of research into drug addiction this raises three interlinked ethical concerns:
  • What counts as a benefit/ risk of harm when it comes to drug addiction?
  • Who should make this decision?
  • Is it acceptable to enrol drug addicts as participants in research that may pose some risk to them, or may not benefit them?

These questions are perhaps easiest to answer when the addict is competent to make the decision for him or herself. In that case the decision is best left to the individual who decides if the benefits/ risks of participation are acceptable.

Where the addict is not competent to make the decision, then there seem to be two ways in which we could go:

  • We might decide on the basis of what the addict would decide to do if he were competent to make the decision themselves,
  • Or we might decide on the basis of what is in his best interests.

Both of these have problems.

The problem with trying to base a decision on what the addict would decide is that it is extremely hard to know what this is. It is a feature of addiction that many addicts seem ambivalent about their drug taking behaviour. They want to stop, and then appear to change their minds and start consuming again.

If we try to decide on the basis of what we judge to be in the addict's best interests this also creates problems for research. It is often held to be problematic to enrol people in research for their own benefit especially if they are competent to make decisions for themselves.

Not all research into addiction aims to benefit the addict himself, and so on this standard using addicts as participants in such research looks ethically problematic.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Addiction Research : The ethical dilemma (Part 1)

There has always been controversy and debate surround the ethics of using addicts in research studies, the one issue I want to examine today surrounds issues around consent/ competence/ voluntariness of the subjects.

A standard requirement for ethically acceptable research is that any human participants have given their consent to take part. For this to be valid consent it must be both voluntary and informed, and the person giving it must be competent to do so.

Perhaps the most common ethical concern with using drug addicts as research participants has been that they are unable to give valid consent either because they lack the competence to do so, or because their participation is not really voluntary.
One of the primary reason for this lies in the very nature of addiction. Strong, perhaps irresistible, desires, difficulty in sticking to decisions to stop taking drugs, and the effects of intoxication and cravings all make for problems in understanding research and making decisions about whether or not to take part in it. How serious these problems are will vary from research project to research project.

This became the subject of particular debate when considering trials of the effectiveness of heroin prescription as a treatment.
One such view widely expressed at the time was that addicts cannot consent to take part in such research as they are unable to refuse to do so, given their craving for the drug. An alternative, and also widely stated view, addicts can agree to take part in such research, as although they have strong desires for drugs they retain the ability to make decisions about what they will do.
Coming out of this debate it would seem that obtaining valid consent from addicts to participate in research can be difficult, and that a range of features need to be considered when doing so, including:

–The nature of the research
–The setting/ context in which consent is obtained
–The nature of any incentives to take part in research
–The complexity of the information that addicts will be required to understand
–The ease with which addicts can withdraw from the research