Saturday, July 2, 2011

Addiction Research : The ethical dilemma (Part 1)

There has always been controversy and debate surround the ethics of using addicts in research studies, the one issue I want to examine today surrounds issues around consent/ competence/ voluntariness of the subjects.

A standard requirement for ethically acceptable research is that any human participants have given their consent to take part. For this to be valid consent it must be both voluntary and informed, and the person giving it must be competent to do so.

Perhaps the most common ethical concern with using drug addicts as research participants has been that they are unable to give valid consent either because they lack the competence to do so, or because their participation is not really voluntary.
One of the primary reason for this lies in the very nature of addiction. Strong, perhaps irresistible, desires, difficulty in sticking to decisions to stop taking drugs, and the effects of intoxication and cravings all make for problems in understanding research and making decisions about whether or not to take part in it. How serious these problems are will vary from research project to research project.

This became the subject of particular debate when considering trials of the effectiveness of heroin prescription as a treatment.
One such view widely expressed at the time was that addicts cannot consent to take part in such research as they are unable to refuse to do so, given their craving for the drug. An alternative, and also widely stated view, addicts can agree to take part in such research, as although they have strong desires for drugs they retain the ability to make decisions about what they will do.
Coming out of this debate it would seem that obtaining valid consent from addicts to participate in research can be difficult, and that a range of features need to be considered when doing so, including:

–The nature of the research
–The setting/ context in which consent is obtained
–The nature of any incentives to take part in research
–The complexity of the information that addicts will be required to understand
–The ease with which addicts can withdraw from the research

No comments:

Post a Comment