In the second of a 3 part series, I will examine another ethical dilemma surrounding the use of addicts as research subjects. In part one I looked at issue surrounding consent. In part 2 I will look at issues surrounding the risks and benefits to the subject.
Different research projects vary in the extent to which they aim to benefit the participants and the risk of harm they contain.
In the context of research into drug addiction this raises three interlinked ethical concerns:
These questions are perhaps easiest to answer when the addict is competent to make the decision for him or herself. In that case the decision is best left to the individual who decides if the benefits/ risks of participation are acceptable.
Where the addict is not competent to make the decision, then there seem to be two ways in which we could go:
Both of these have problems.
The problem with trying to base a decision on what the addict would decide is that it is extremely hard to know what this is. It is a feature of addiction that many addicts seem ambivalent about their drug taking behaviour. They want to stop, and then appear to change their minds and start consuming again.
If we try to decide on the basis of what we judge to be in the addict's best interests this also creates problems for research. It is often held to be problematic to enrol people in research for their own benefit especially if they are competent to make decisions for themselves.
Not all research into addiction aims to benefit the addict himself, and so on this standard using addicts as participants in such research looks ethically problematic.
Different research projects vary in the extent to which they aim to benefit the participants and the risk of harm they contain.
In the context of research into drug addiction this raises three interlinked ethical concerns:
- What counts as a benefit/ risk of harm when it comes to drug addiction?
- Who should make this decision?
- Is it acceptable to enrol drug addicts as participants in research that may pose some risk to them, or may not benefit them?
These questions are perhaps easiest to answer when the addict is competent to make the decision for him or herself. In that case the decision is best left to the individual who decides if the benefits/ risks of participation are acceptable.
Where the addict is not competent to make the decision, then there seem to be two ways in which we could go:
- We might decide on the basis of what the addict would decide to do if he were competent to make the decision themselves,
- Or we might decide on the basis of what is in his best interests.
Both of these have problems.
The problem with trying to base a decision on what the addict would decide is that it is extremely hard to know what this is. It is a feature of addiction that many addicts seem ambivalent about their drug taking behaviour. They want to stop, and then appear to change their minds and start consuming again.
If we try to decide on the basis of what we judge to be in the addict's best interests this also creates problems for research. It is often held to be problematic to enrol people in research for their own benefit especially if they are competent to make decisions for themselves.
Not all research into addiction aims to benefit the addict himself, and so on this standard using addicts as participants in such research looks ethically problematic.
No comments:
Post a Comment